57 Tandberg Trail Ste 7, Windham, ME 04062 (207) 893-8184
Car Insurance

Switching could help you save!

Motorcycle Insurance

Make sure that you motorcycle is insured, ready for your adventures!

Homeowners Insurance

Jonathan can offer you home insurance that offers discounts and benefits.

previous arrow
next arrow


Whatever you drive, you need insurance. Farmers has coverage options that enable you to get the auto insurance policy that best fits your lifestyle.


No matter the type of business, we can help you customize an insurance package to reduce your risk and protect your investment.


Your home coverage needs to reflect what really matters to you. Our customizable packages allow you to protect what’s most important.


Life insurance can be there when it’s needed most by your loved ones. It's more affordable than you think to protect the future of your family.

Our agents are local, independent, and ready to help you.

At Jonathan Priest Insurance, Inc. in Windham, Maine, our agents get to know you so they can create customized insurance policies to fit your needs. We believe the first step to the right coverage begins with education – you tell us about your life, work and interests, and we coach you on the best insurance policies to protect what you hold dear.

Having the right insurance coverage means:

  • Peace of Mind
  • Comfort
  • Security
  • Safeguarding Your Future

Protect everything that you have worked for and created in your life and business.

Demystifying Insurance

Insurance coverage comes with many options to consider – minimum coverage requirements, deductibles, replacement costs, liability limits, the list goes on. It can be mysterious and confusing. Our first goal is to make sure we understand your unique lifestyle and insurance needs, then discuss options with you. Considering different scenarios helps our clients see the impact of insurance coverage on their quality of life and peace of mind. We want to make sure everyone fully understands their insurance options so you can make the right choices for you.

When you fully understand your coverage options – you can make the best choice for you, your family, and your business.

Financial Well-Being

Many people don’t consider insurance an important financial tool, but it actually has a huge impact on your financial well-being. It can help you live life with fewer worries knowing you will have financial support and protection should unforeseen events occur. It can mean protecting your home and other assets, ensuring your kids can go to college, completing home or business repairs to protect your equity, and affording repairs or a replacement vehicle after an accident. Protecting you financially is the purpose of insurance.

Choices about insurance coverage can really impact your financial wellbeing.

Design slant for background

Guaranteed Replacement Cost

100% of the cost of rebuilding your home can be covered at Farmers!

Farmers Smart Plan Home® policy uses three highly customizable packages as a starting point, with an option for an uncapped replacement cost which will reimburse 100% of the cost of rebuilding after a covered loss on the same premises, regardless of your policy’s limits.

Insurance app

Guaranteed Replacement Cost:

  • Replacement cost is the total cost to rebuild your house from scratch reflecting today’s prices, construction methods and building codes.
  • This figure can be higher than your home’s actual value.
  • The replacement cost of your home can increase following a catastrophic event results in greater demand for labor and materials.

J. Priest Insurance Serves All of Maine, New Hampshire and Massachusetts

Jonathan Priest is the New Board Chair of the Sebago Lakes Region Chamber

At the recent Chamber’s Annual Meeting and Awards Dinner held on Thursday, Jan. 18, the chamber voted Jonathan Priest of J. Priest Insurance to succeed Jennifer Arsenault of Edward Jones as the new Board Chair. The Sebago Lakes Region Chamber of Commerce has been serving the Windham and Lakes Region…

Read Full Article >>


Homeowner’s Guide to Fall Home Maintenance

Fall brings colorful leaves and cooler temperatures, but seasonal home care should also be on the calendar because winter has no mercy on homes unprepared for its surprises. Here are some fall home maintenance tips that will save you from expensive repairs in the future. GET A QUOTE Roof and…

Read Full Article >>

For Home Owners

Mortgage Insurance – It happened, it’s happening, or it’s about to happen!

It happened, it’s happening, or it’s about to happen! You’re a homeowner, in the process of qualifying for a mortgage, or maybe you just took advantage of these super-low interest rates to refinance. There are a million pieces of paperwork to review and file, and offers from companies to replace…

Read Full Article >>

For Home Owners

keys to the house, but is the home insured?


Jonathan was amazing! Nothing stresses me out more than insurance shopping and he made it SO easy. He always responds in a timely manner and best of all, saved me almost 900$ per year on home and auto!


Jonathan is great! we were introduced to him when we bought our last fall. He has jumped through hoops to get us the coverage we need at a great price. If I need anything, no matter how big or small, is on it and very responsive. Thank you!


Can’t say enough good things about Jonathan! He was so helpful, responded in a timely manner and actually took time to explain things to me with no judgement as I know very little about insurance and how it works. I would recommend him to anyone looking for insurance!